Advertisement
The 7 Scariest Players in NFL History Are Truly Terrifying
Rob Tringali/SportsChrome/Getty Images (left), Focus on Sport/Getty Images (right)

The NFL is full of guys you don’t want to mess with. We’re talking about guys who make a living by crushing and bulldozing 17 weeks a year. That in itself is more than enough for me to ensure I’m on their good side.

Then there are the guys the guys you don’t want to mess with don’t want to mess with. These are the meanest of the mean and the baddest of the bad. Guys like this are respectfully referred to as “dudes.” A guy plays in the NFL. A dude instills fear.

The league has seen plenty of these mean, tough and downright scary players throughout its century-long history. From the days when helmets were made of leather to now, here are seven of the scariest players in NFL history.

The 7 Scariest Players in NFL History

7. James Harrison, Pittsburgh Steelers

James Harrison walks out before a Steelers game in 2015.
Photo by Justin K. Aller/Getty Images

Speaking of guys with scary frames, that brings us to James Harrison. Harrison, who also played for the Baltimore Ravens, Cincinnati Bengals and New England Patriots, was famous for his insane workouts and violent hits in the open field. Quarterbacks always had to make sure where Harrison was lined up or else their head might be taken off.

6. Dick Lane, Detroit Lions

Dick Lane for the Detroit Lions.
Bettmann / Contributor / Getty Images

I’m a sucker for great football nicknames, and Dick “Night Train” Lane is an all-timer. “Night Train” is the reason we have the facemask penalty. Back in 1961, the cornerback threw running back Jon Arnett to the ground by the facemask so hard the league prohibited the technique the next year.

Lane, who suited up for the Los Angeles Rams and Arizona Cardinals in addition to the Lions, was notorious for tackling around the head and neck, inspiring his unique method to be named the “Night Train Necktie.” He’s the driving force behind many illegal tackling rules in the game today.

Advertisement

5. Ray Lewis, Baltimore Ravens

Ray Lewis grins during the Super Bowl in 2013.
Photo by Chris Graythen/Getty Images

RELATED: The 11 Strongest Arms in NFL History Could Throw it a Country Mile

Plenty of ball carriers were sore on the other end of Lewis’ 1,568 career tackles, which ranks first all time in NFL history. The Baltimore Ravens legend was the anchor of some of the meanest defenses the game has ever seen and played with a fire that made offenses quiver. On top of two Super Bowls, Lewis is among the greatest defensive players the league of all time.

4. Jack Tatum, Oakland Raiders

Jack Tatum stands on the sidelines for the Raiders.
Photo by Michael Zagaris/Getty Images

When you’re referred to as “The Assassin,” you automatically get a spot on the list. Get this: Tatum knocked out two guys in the first game of his NFL career. He once paralyzed a dude from a hit so hard. He became the last guy you wanted to see over the middle of the field from that point on. Just ask Minnesota Vikings wide receiver Sammy White, who the defensive back smoked in Super Bowl XI.

3. Jack Youngblood, Los Angeles Rams

Jack Youngblood of the Los Angeles Rams circa 1984 at Anaheim Stadium in Anaheim, California.
Photo by Owen C. Shaw/Getty Images

Nothing could stop Los Angeles Rams defensive end Jack Youngblood, and I mean nothing. The Florida native played the entire 1979 playoffs, including Super Bowl XIV, with a broken leg and still played in the Pro Bowl a week later. No one in their right mind would think of doing that today.

Advertisement

Despite the broken leg and several other injuries, the Hall of Fame defender played in 201 consecutive games and only missed one in his entire 14-year career. Anybody who’s willing to gut it out to that extent is one scary dude

2. Dick Butkus, Chicago Bears

Dick Butkus poses for a picture for the Chicago Bears.
Bettmann / Contributor / Getty Images

Perhaps the hardest hitter in NFL history, Dick Butkus had a motor that never stopped. At 6-foot-3 and 245 pounds, Butkus’ speed, strength and animal instinct are something out of a folk tale. The Chicago Bears icon had a reputation for snarling at opponents prior to the snap and biting them in pileups. He was willing to put any part of his body on the line.

1. Lawrence Taylor, New York Giants

Lawrence Taylor during a 1989 NFL game.
Photo by Mike Powell/Allsport/Getty Images

It was never a doubt Lawrence Taylor was going to be No. 1 on this list. The eight-time First-team All-Pro linebacker was a mad man whenever he strapped on the helmet.

The former New York Giants star is the only defensive player other than Vikings defensive tackle Alan Page to take home the NFL MVP award. The same year, 1986, Taylor won the NFL Defensive Player of the Year Award and led the Giants to a victory in Super Bowl XXI. He was so fearsome that legendary head coaches such as Joe Gibbs and Bill Walsh designed entirely new schemes to prevent him from making plays. There is simply no NFL player like LT.

Advertisement

Honorable Mentions:

Myles Garrett, Cleveland Browns

Conrad Dobler, St. Louis Cardinals

John Lynch, Safety, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Deacon Jones, Los Angeles Rams

Ed Reed, Baltimore Ravens

Brian Cushing, Houston Texans

Mike Ditka, Chicago Bears

Jim Taylor, Fullback, Green Bay Packers

John Matuszak, Oakland/Los Angeles Raiders

MORE: Lawrence Taylor’s Net Worth: How “LT” Lost $50 Million

Related Videos

Joe Grobeck About the author:
Joe is a graduate of the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and lives in Austin, Texas. He believes Ndaumkong Suh should've won the 2009 Heisman and is an avid basketball fan.
View More Articles

Stories You Might Like