Quirky trick plays are the staple of any exciting postgame discussion. While it’s really uncommon for many gadget plays to work to perfection, their bizarre nature comes as a welcome treat every time a team pulls one off. When it comes to the NFL though, crazy rulings are more common than trick plays these days.
While NFL rules can be confusing at times, there is one rule that no one has ever seen applied in an actual game, and we almost saw it during the New England Patriots rout of their divisional rival on Monday Night Football. Yes, the one-point safety is a real thing, and leave it to the Buffalo Bills to almost surrender the first one in NFL history.
According to the NFL’s scoring rules under Section 11-3-2-C, the rare one-point safety is awarded when a safety occurs by either team during a “try,” or a point after try such as a two-point conversion or extra point attempt.
When the Patriots lined up for a two-point conversion following James White’s one-yard rushing touchdown, Tom Brady’s pass to Cordarrelle Patterson was intercepted by Bills linebacker Julian Stanford. When Stanford started to bring the ball out of the end zone, he fumbled the ball before crossing the goal line, and it was recovered by Buffalo in the end zone.
Now, if the defensive player had crossed the plane and fumbled, then Buffalo recovered the football back inside the end zone, it would by rule be a safety, and New England would have been awarded a single point.
Football Zebras described what the wild ruling would have been had it been recognized, and confirmed that it has never been applied in the NFL before.
Welcome to a world where you now know that the one-point safety is actually a legitimate thing.
It’s so rare that Quirky Research only found five previous applications of the rule in NCAA history, and only twice has it happened in a major Division I college football game. One of them occurred during a 2004 meeting between Texas and Texas A&M, and the other happened on a strange sequence during the 2013 Fiesta Bowl between the Oregon Ducks and Kansas State Wildcats.
New England didn’t need the two-point conversion attempt, extra point, or the 1-point safety during their 25-6 dismantling of an over-matched Buffalo Bills team. Tom Brady threw for 324 yards and cornerback Devin McCourty sealed the game with an 84-yard interception return for a touchdown.
The next time your team is lining up to defend a point-after attempt, hold your breath because the first case of the one-point safety could strike the NFL at any time.