The Florida State Seminoles took down the No. 1 Oklahoma Sooners in Game 1 of the Women’s College World Series Championship using some timely defense, a barrage of hits, and a very controversial play at home plate.
In the seventh inning, an obstruction call awarded a run (and an even larger lead) for FSU. The bang-bang play and decisive call made by the home plate umpire became a major talking point for both fanbases and the rest of college softball fans.
So, was obstruction really the right call?
FSU-Oklahoma WCWS Obstruction Call
Florida State led 7-4 in the top of the seventh inning inside Oklahoma City’s Hall of Fame Stadium on Tuesday night.
FSU’s Kalei Harding singled to left field, and runner Josie Muffley rounded third but didn’t head home thanks to a strong throw from Oklahoma left fielder Mackenzie Donihoo.
Meanwhile, FSU’s Anna Shelnutt got caught in a rundown between second and third base. OU catcher Lynnsie Elam fired to second behind her. Then, Muffley sprinted home. Oklahoma Tiare Jennings quickly threw home.
Elam received the ball before Muffley slid, but was called for obstruction by home plate umpire Don Brown because she put her knee down before receiving the ball, thus blocking Muffley’s path to the plate. Muffley was also injured on the play.
The call was pivotal. The Seminoles went up 8-4 and hung on to win after a Sooner rally in the bottom of the seventh.
What’s interesting is that umpires missed what could have been an interference call when the FSU third base coach touched Muffley to send her back to third base on the play:
The obstruction call led to an outcry by Oklahoma fans on social media, but the NCAA stood behind the call.
NCAA Says Call Was “Made Correctly”
The NCAA stood by the umpire’s obstruction call after the game.
Here’s what NCAA Secretary Rules-Editor Vickie Van Kleeck said about the call:
“When the catcher put her knee down before catching the ball, that does constitute as blocking the plate because she cannot be in that position blocking the path of the runner or blocking the plate without possession of the ball. Thus the obstruction call was made correctly.Advertisement
“The runner has to be given an opportunity to reach the plate, and in this case with the knee down without the ball, that is why obstruction was charged to the catcher.”
Was she blocking the entire plate? It looked to some like she gave the lower left half of the plate.
Another issue: Elam had no choice but to stand in the way of the runner because she was awaiting a throw that took her in the runner’s path. She would’ve had to have caught the ball in front of the base path, but she didn’t have time on a throw from the infield.
According to the NCAA Softball rulebook, obstruction “occurs when a defensive player, not in possession of the ball nor in the act of fielding a batted ball, impedes a batter’s attempt to make contact with a pitch or impedes the progress of any runner who is legally running bases on a live ball.”
The rulebook goes on to state that “defensive players must catch the ball, block the base and make the tag” rather than blocking the base before catching the ball.
It’s a tricky call, and it encourages a runner to attempt to make contact to get obstruction called. Muffley could have just as easily slid slightly to her right and swiped the plate with her hand.
Oklahoma Head Coach: “It Hurt Us”
Oklahoma head coach Patty Gasso offered her thoughts about the controversial call in a postgame press conference.
“It hurt us,” Gasso said. “That call hurt us. And all I can say is that I wish that rule was looked at a little bit differently because there’s a lot of ways that you can look at it. And I guess I’ll just leave it right there at that. I’m sorry that the young lady got hurt. That’s not the intention whatsoever. But I just am going to leave it right there. It’s a tough rule. It’s a tough, tough rule for all teams who are trying to be aggressive and umpires are trying to do the right thing. It’s something that is tough. And you just hate the fact that it’s at home plate because it’s going to lead to a run or cost a run, one way or the other. So it was a tough play.”
The Sooners, despite back-to-back home runs and a late-game rally, ultimately fell to the Seminoles. FSU softball is now just one win away from a second national championship in that last three tournaments.