Winston, just months after winning the Heisman Trophy, was given a citation for stealing $32.72 worth of crab legs and crawfish from a Tallahassee Publix grocery store on April 29th, 2014, adding to a list of issues Winston had while attending Florida State University.
After the incident, Winston claimed he had planned on paying for his food when he arrived at the store, but made a poor decision based out of basically being a dumb kid, though he was a 20-year-old that continued to make poor decisions after the incident.
“As reported in the news, last night I received an adult civil citation for petit theft from a local supermarket. I went to the supermarket with the intent to purchase dinner but made a terrible mistake for which I’m taking full responsibility. In a moment of youthful ignorance, I walked out of the store without paying for one of my items.”
— Jameis Winston, h/t Pro Football Talk
But about 10 months after the incident, he changed his story. In an interview on ESPN’s Draft Academy with Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh before the NFL Draft and being taken with the first-overall pick by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Winston claimed it wasn’t an accident.
Apparently about a week before taking the crab legs, a Publix employee had told Winston he could take a birthday cake he was there to pick up, and the employee would “hook him up” with free food whenever he went to the store.
“Well, a week before, it was my buddy’s birthday and we had got a cake. And we met a dude that worked inside Publix and he said, ‘Hey, anytime you come in here, I got you.’ So that day we just walked out and he hooked us up with that. When I came in to get crab legs, did the same thing, and he just gave them to me, and I walked out.”
— Jameis Winston in ESPN Draft Academy interview
If this is the case, it isn’t something anyone knew about because not even Seminoles head coach Jimbo Fisher knew about this at the time, which is something I would think Winston would mention when meeting with his coach.
“I had no knowledge of it until I came in this morning. But FSU, we did make contact with Publix back then to make sure there was nothing going on.”
— Jimbo Fisher during 2015 ACC Teleconference
Publix apparently looked into a store employee giving away food to Winston, but they found nothing that could confirm the truth behind Winston’s statement.
The Heisman Trophy winner was playing on the Florida State baseball team at the time and was suspended by coach Mike Martin for the citation. He was reinstated five days later after completing his hours of community service.
This wasn’t the first time, nor the last, that Winston ran into trouble during his time in college.
Nov. 25, 2012: Pellet Guns
Winston and his roommate, FSU defensive end Chris Casher, were reported to be shooting pellet guns at squirrels. Police approached the two with guns drawn and handcuffed them, but they were released without charges being filed.
Later in the night, Winston, Casher, Mario Edwards, and P.J. Williams took part in a pellet and B.B. gun battle, causing $4 thousand in damages at their apartment building. Management didn’t press charges because an FSU official promised they would pay back the building for the damages caused.
Dec. 7, 2012: Sexual Assault Allegations
A woman accused Winston of raping her in his apartment, after which she immediately reported the incident to the police. Five weeks later, she reached out to investigators and told them it was Winston who had committed the assault after recognizing him on campus. Charges were dismissed by Tallahassee Police after saying the accuser wasn’t cooperating.
The investigation was continued nine months later, but was dropped again when it was decided there wasn’t enough evidence. It was investigated by the NCAA and Department of Education for nearly two years and became a major controversy during Winston’s Heisman season.
July 21, 2013: Burger King Soda
Winston was accused by a Burger King employee of entering the store and began filling up empty ketchup cups with soda without paying, even after being told not to.
The store manager dropped the case and no charges were filed.
May 20, 2014: Code-of-Conduct Meeting
Winston was absent from a code-of-conduct hearing on Florida State’s campus with Casher and Ronald Darby, who supposedly witnessed parts of the sexual encounter with the woman who had accused Winston of rape. He claimed no one had told him he needed to be there, and it was decided they could not do anything to force him to attend the hearing.
Sept. 16, 2014: Student Center
Winston jumped onto a table in a campus building on September 16, 2014 and yelled “F*** her in the p****.” The whole thing was seen by multiple students and leads to Fisher suspend him for the first half of the team’s game against the Clemson Tigers.
During his time in the NFL, Winston was suspended three games during the 2018 season after he “violated the Personal Conduct Policy by touching the driver in an inappropriate and sexual manner without her consent.”
Winston’s troubles off the field are well-documented, and it’s unfortunately put a stain on his football career.